The web professional's online magazine of choice.
By Jesse Nieminen
February 26, 2003
November 3, 2004 6:23 PM
Thank you this was very informative!
January 5, 2005 1:17 AM
Henning von Vogelsang
June 21, 2005 7:33 AM
One of the rare fair articles about the two competing solutions. However, I disagree with the comparison of interfaces and I think you’re missing a few important points.
GoLive’s bloated interface: Like in most Adobe applications, one can modify the number of palettes, as well as the number and order of tabs within palette windows.
Harder to learn: Neither Dreamweaver nor GoLive can remove the fact it is hard to learn HTML or CSS for a new designer, who gets in touch with web design for the first time. Dreamweaver however reduces the impact of this fact by providing easier access, or a not so steep learning curve. As a trade in, Dreamweaver produces malicious code by default, proprietary code that is hard to edit without using Dreamweaver (template files). In combination with Fireworks’ slicing function, which is a popular feature used by newbie web designers, the results are even worse. You will find thousands of redundant files in media- and html folders, often carrying numbers for names, making it hard to identify files once you have to make changes.
While I agree that there are specific improvements required, especially in terms of XML and true visual CSS layout editing, I’m positive Adobe will clean up a lot once they will merge teams with previous Dreamweaver developers. It’s clear to me the two applications will be joined, now that Adobe has purchased Macromedia. Hopefully, this will mean a benefit for all of us and not result in multiplication of bloated features.
July 11, 2005 8:23 PM
I find GL easier to learn, but if you want your sites coded by hand look elsewhere. Owerall i tested both programs and found that GL bas better html output then DW (in WYSIWYG mode)
You can use this feed to keep up with the comments made on this article.
Copyright © 1994-2013 Digital Web Magazine. All Rights Reserved.